Due dates: I've picked May 6, but any of the proposed due dates is fine for me.
Comments: I haven't kept track on the extent of non-commenting. But since the issue is of relevance for the upcoming game, it appears to be extensive. I've tried to think about what might keep people from commenting: a) ignorance, b) Is it possible that people feel overwhelmed by some of the more extensive comments, feel pressured to provide something similar and prefer not to comment at all instead? c) People don't like the story written for them and rather don't comment before writing something that might disappoint the author. If it's simple ignorance, then a ban of one game may be justified. But if it's b or c, a ban might be too hard and lead to the loss of participants. Therefore, I think trying this year kudos as minimum requirement and see how far we get with that, or one sentence, whereby a simple thanks should suffice.
Re: Please share anywhere you like
I've picked May 6, but any of the proposed due dates is fine for me.
Comments:
I haven't kept track on the extent of non-commenting. But since the issue is of relevance for the upcoming game, it appears to be extensive. I've tried to think about what might keep people from commenting:
a) ignorance,
b) Is it possible that people feel overwhelmed by some of the more extensive comments, feel pressured to provide something similar and prefer not to comment at all instead?
c) People don't like the story written for them and rather don't comment before writing something that might disappoint the author.
If it's simple ignorance, then a ban of one game may be justified. But if it's b or c, a ban might be too hard and lead to the loss of participants. Therefore, I think trying this year kudos as minimum requirement and see how far we get with that, or one sentence, whereby a simple thanks should suffice.